Google Maps API No Longer Free? (Shallow Thoughts)

Google Maps API No Longer Free?

A while ago I wrote an interactive trail map page for the PEEC nature center website. At the time, I wanted to use an open library, like OpenLayers or Leaflet; but there were no good sources of satellite/aerial map tiles at the time. The only one I found didn't work because they had a big blank area anywhere near LANL -- maybe because of the restricted airspace around the Lab. Anyway, I figured people would want a satellite option, so I used Google Maps instead despite its much more frustrating API.

This week we've been working on converting the website to https. Most things went surprisingly smoothly (though we had a lot more absolute URLs in our pages and databases than we'd realized). But when we got through, I discovered the trail map was broken. I'm still not clear why, but somehow the change from http to https made Google's API stop working. In trying to fix the problem, I discovered that Google's map API may soon cease to be free:

New pricing and product changes will go into effect starting June 11, 2018. For more information, check out the Guide for Existing Users.

That has a button for "Transition Tool" which, when you click it, won't tell you anything about the new pricing structure until you've already set up a billing account. Um ... no thanks, Google.

Googling for google maps api billing led to a page headed "Pricing that scales to fit your needs", which has an elaborate pricing structure listing a whole bnch of variants (I have no idea which of these I was using), of which the first $200/month is free. But since they insist on setting up a billing account, I'd probably have to give them a credit card number -- which one? My personal credit card, for a page that isn't even on my site? Does the nonprofit nature center even have a credit card? How many of these API calls is their site likely to get in a month, and what are the chances of going over the limit?

It all rubbed me the wrong way, especially when the context of "Your trail maps page that real people actually use has broken without warning, and will be held hostage until you give usa credit card number". This is what one gets for using a supposedly free (as in beer) library that's not Free open source software.

So I replaced Google with the excellent open source Leaflet library, which, as a bonus, has much better documentation than Google Maps. (It's not that Google's documentation is poorly written; it's that they keep changing their APIs, but there's no way to tell the dozen or so different APIs apart because they're all just called "Maps", so when you search for documentation you're almost guaranteed to get something that stopped working six years ago -- but the documentation is still there making it look like it's still valid.) And I was happy to discover that, in the time since I originally set up the trailmap page, some open providers of aerial/satellite map tiles have appeared. So we can use open source and have a satellite view.

Our trail map is back online with Leaflet, and with any luck, this time it will keep working. PEEC Los Alamos Area Trail Map.