Shallow Thoughts : : gimp

Akkana's Musings on Open Source Computing and Technology, Science, and Nature.

Thu, 06 Nov 2014

New GIMP Save/Export plug-in: Saver

The split between Save and Export that GIMP introduced in version 2.8 has been a matter of much controversy. It's been over two years now, and people are still complaining on the gimp-users list.

Early on, I wrote a simple Python plug-in called Save-Export Clean, which saved over an image's current save or export filename regardless of whether the filename was XCF (save) or a different format (export). The idea was that you could bind Ctrl-S to the plug-in and not be pestered by needing to remember whether it was XCF, JPG or what.

Save-Export Clean has been widely cited, and I hope it's helped some people who were bothered by the Save/Export split. But personally I didn't like it very much. It wasn't very flexible -- there was no way to change the filename, for one thing, and it was awfully easy to overwrite an original image without knowing that you'd done it. I went back to using GIMP's separate Save and Export, but in the back of my mind I was turning over ideas, trying to understand my workflow and what I really wanted out of a GIMP Save plug-in.

[Screenshot: GIMP Saver-as... plug-in] The result of that was a new Python plug-in called Saver. I first wrote it a year ago, but I've been tweaking it and using it since then, with Ctrl-S bound to Saverand Ctrl-Shift-S bound to Saver as...). I wanted to make sure that it was useful and working reliably ... and somehow I never got around to writing it up and announcing it formally ... until now.

Saver, like Save/Export Clean, will overwrite your chosen filename, whether XCF or another format, and will mark the image as saved so GIMP won't pester you when you exit.

What's different? Mainly, three things:

  1. A Saver as... option so you can change the filename or file type.
  2. Merges multiple layers so they'll show up properly in your JPG or PNG image.
  3. An option to save as .xcf or .xcf.gz and, at the same time, export a copy in another format, possibly scaled down. So you can maintain your multi-layer XCF image but also update the JPG copy that you're going to put on the web.

I've been using Saver for nearly all my saving for the past year. If I'm just making a quick edit of a JPEG camera image, Ctrl-S overwrites it without questioning me. If I'm editing an elaborate multi-layer GIMP project, Ctrl-S overwrites the .xcf.gz. If I'm planning to export that image for the web, I Ctrl-Shift-S to bring up the Saver As... dialog, make sure the main filename is .xcf.gz, set a name (ending in .jpg) for the exported copy; and from then on, Ctrl-S will save both the XCF and the JPG copy.

Saver is available on my github page, with installation instructions here: GIMP Saver and Save/Export Clean Plug-ins. I hope you find it useful.

Tags:
[ 12:57 Nov 06, 2014    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Fri, 13 Sep 2013

GIMP menu placeholders

Someone on the gimp-developers list asked whether there was documentation of GIMP's menu hooks.

I wasn't sure what they meant by "hooks", but GIMP menus do have an interesting feature that plug-in writers should know about: placeholders.

Placeholders let you group similar types of actions together. For instance, iever notice that in the image window's File menu, all the things that Open images are grouped together? There's Open, Open as Layers..., Open Location... and Open Recent. And then there's a group of Save actions all grouped together -- Save, Save As..., Save a Copy... and so forth. That's because there's a placeholder for Open in the File menu, and another placeholder for Save.

When you write your own plug-ins, you can take advantage of these placeholders. For instance, I want my Save/Export clean plug-in to show up next to the other Save menu items, not somewhere else down near the bottom of the menu -- so when I register it, I pass menu = "<Image>/File/Save/" so GIMP knows to group it with the other Save actions, even though it's directly in the File menu, not a submenu called Save..

Pretty slick, huh? But how do you know what placeholders are available?

I took a look at the source. In the menus/ subdirectory are all the menu definitions in XML, and they're pretty straightforward. In image-menu.xml you'll see things like <placeholder name="Open">, <placeholder name="Save">

So to get a list of all the menu placeholders, you just need to find all the " grep '<placeholder' menus/*.xml

That's not actually so useful, though, because it doesn't tell you what submenu contains the placeholder. For instance, Acquire is a placeholder but you need to know that it's actually File->Create->Acquire. So let's be a little more clever.

We want to see <menu lines as well as <placeholders, but not <menuitem since those are just individual menu entries. egrep '<(placeholder|menu) will do that. Then pass it through some sed expressions to clean up the output, loop over all the XML files, and I ended up with:

for f in *.xml; do
  echo $f
  egrep '<(placeholder|menu) ' $f | sed -e 's_<placeholder *name="_** _' -e 's_<menu.*name="__' -e 's_"/*>__'
done

It isn't perfect: a few lines still show up that shouldn't -- but it'll get you the list you need. Fortunately the GIMP developers are very good about things like code formatting, so the identation of the file shows which placeholder is inside which submenu.

I only found placeholders in the image window menu, plus a single placeholder, "Outline", in the selection menu popup. I'm a little confused about that menu file: it seems to duplicate the existing Select menu in the image-menu.xml, except that the placeholder items in question -- feather, sharpen, shrink, grow, and border -- are in a placeholder called Outline in selection-menu.xml, but in a placeholder called Modify in image-menu.xml.

Anyway, here's the full list of placeholders, cleaned up for readability. Placeholders are in bold and followed with an asterisk *.

===== image-menu.xml =====
    File
      Create
        Acquire *
      Open *
      Open Recent
        Files *
      Debug
      Save *
      Export *
      Send *
      Info *
    Context
    Edit
      Undo *
      Cut *
      Copy *
      Paste *
      Paste as
      Buffer
      Clear *
      Fill *
      Stroke *
      Preferences *
    Select
      Modify *
    View
    Image
      New *
      Mode
        Color Profile *
      Precision
      Transform
        Flip *
        Rotate *
      Resize *
      Scale *
      Crop *
      Structure *
      Arrange *
      Guides
    Layer
      New *
      Structure *
      Text *
      Stack
        Select *
        Position *
      Mask
        Modify *
        Properties *
        Selection *
      Transparency
        Modify *
        Selection *
      Transform
        Flip *
        Rotate *
      Properties
        Opacity
        Layer Mode
      Resize *
      Scale *
      Crop *
    Colors
      Invert *
      Auto
      Components
      Desaturate
      Map
        Colormap *
      Info
      Modify *
    Tools
    Filters
      Recently Used
        Plug-Ins *
      Blur
        Motion *
      Enhance
      Distorts
      Light and Shadow
        Light *
        Shadow *
        Glass *
      Noise
      Edge-Detect
      Generic
      Combine
      Artistic
      Decor
      Map
      Render
        Clouds
        Nature
        Pattern
      Web
      Animation
        Animators *
      Menus *
      Languages *
      Extensions *
    Menus *
    Windows
      Recently Closed Docks
      Dockable Dialogs
      Images *
      Docks *
    Help
      Programming *

===== selection-menu.xml =====
    Outline *

Tags: ,
[ 19:06 Sep 13, 2013    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Wed, 27 Feb 2013

Printing in Landscape orientation in GIMP (and some spinbutton tips)

I was printing out a map for a new trail we wanted to hike. I wanted to fill the paper with the map -- Google maps' print and Firefox's print, while fine for most map printing, weren't what I wanted.

So I took a screenshot of the maximized browser window with the map in it and imported it into GIMP. In the Crop tool, I constrained Aspect-ratio to 11:8.5 and cropped the image so it would just fit on a page, in landscape format -- wider in east-west than in north-south. Then I chose File->Print.

[GIMP printing dialog] Since printing defaults to Portrait orientation, I went to the Page Setup tab and changed Orientation to Landscape. (It's so nice to have that as part of the dialog. I'm forever amazed at how some apps, like Firefox, make you use a separate dialog first to change the print's orientation. How can anyone possibly see that as sensible UI design?)

Unfortunately, When I went to the Image Settings tab to check , I discovered that GIMP hadn't adjusted the image size when I changed to Landscape. It had Width listed as 8.500, Height as 6.567, and the image only took up part of the page.

I went to the Width field and replaced 8.500 with 11, and hit Tab. Whoops! The field reverted to 8.500. The same thing happened if I tried typing 8.5 into the Height field.

These fields aren't plain text entries -- they're "spin boxes", with a text entry plus up and down arrows. It turned out that under GIMP 2.8 and earlier, round-off errors sometimes prevent you from setting a spin box's maximum value. I could type 10.999 and it would work fine, but 11 or 11.0 failed.

Of course, 10.999 would have been fine -- I don't mind a little margin on a printed map. It's also trivial in GIMP to rotate a landscape photo 90 degrees and print it in portrait orientation. But by this point I was into stubborn mode -- by gosh, I wanted a way to fix this!

The best workaround, it turns out, is to use the spin box's up-arrow. Holding the mouse down over the up arrow will eventually get to the maximum value. But there's a faster way: right-clicking on the up-arrow goes straight to the maximum value. A nice trick!

The problem doesn't exist in GIMP 2.9 -- I reported it as bug 694477, and the awesome GIMP team fixed it very quickly. The spin boxes work beautifully now. (Thanks, Mitch!) But as long as 2.8 is around, or for any other app using spin boxes, I'm glad to know about right-clicking on the spin box arrows.

Tags: ,
[ 12:26 Feb 27, 2013    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Sun, 02 Sep 2012

GIMP plug-in to export scaled-down versions of images

In a discussion on Google+arising from my Save/Export clean plug-in, someone said to the world in general

PLEASE provide an option to select the size of the export. Having to scale the XCF then export then throw out the result without saving is really awkward.

I thought, What a good idea! Suppose you're editing a large image, with layers and text and other jazz, saving in GIMP's native XCF format, but you want to export a smaller version for the web. Every time you make a significant change, you have to: Scale (remembering the scale size or percentage you're targeting); Save a Copy (or Export in GIMP 2.8); then Undo the Scale. If you forget the Undo, you're in deep trouble and might end up overwriting the XCF original with a scaled-down version.

If I had a plug-in that would export to another file type (such as JPG) with a scale factor, remembering that scale factor so I didn't have to, it would save me both effort and risk.

And that sounded pretty easy to write, using some of the tricks I'd learned from my Save/Export Clean and wallpaper scripts. So I wrote export-scaled.py

It's still brand new, so if anyone tries it, I'd appreciate knowing if it's useful or if you have any problems with it.

Geeky programming commentary

(Folks not interested in the programming details can stop reading now.)

Linked input fields

[screenshot: linked input fields] One fun project was writing a set of linked text entries for the dialog:
Scale to: Percentage 100 % Width: 640 Height: 480

Change any one of the three, and the other two change automatically. There's no chain link between width and height: It's assumed that if you're exporting a scaled copy, you won't want to change the image's aspect ratio, so any one of the three is enough.

That turned out to be surprisingly hard to do with GTK SpinBoxes: I had to read their values as strings and parse them, because the numeric values kept snapping back to their original values as soon as focus went to another field.

Image parasites

Another fun challenge was how to save the scale ratio, so the second time you call up the plug-in on the same image it uses whatever values you used the first time. If you're going to scale to 50%, you don't want to have to type that in every time. And of course, you want it to remember the exported file path, so you don't have to navigate there every time.

For that, I used GIMP parasites: little arbitrary pieces of data you can attach to any image. I've known about parasites for a long time, but I'd never had occasion to use them in a Python plug-in before. I was pleased to find that they were documented in the official GIMP Python documentation, and they worked just as documented. It was easy to test them, too: in the Python console (Filters->Python->Console...), type something like

img = gimp_image_list()[0]
img.parasite_list()
img.parasite_find(img.parasite_list()[0])
and so forth. Nice!

Not prompting for JPG settings

My plug-in was almost done. But when I ran it and told it to save to filenamecopy.jpg, it prompted me with that annoying JPEG settings dialog. Okay, being prompted once isn't so bad. But then when I exported a second time, it prompted me again, and didn't remember the values from before. So the question was, what controls whether the settings dialog is shown, and how could I prevent it?

Of course, I could prompt the user for JPEG quality, then call jpeg-save-file directly -- but what if you want to export to PNG or GIF or some other format? I needed something more general

Turns out, nobody really remembers how this works, and it's not documented anywhere. Some people thought that passing run_mode=RUN_WITH_LAST_VALS when I called pdb.gimp_file_save() would do the trick, but it didn't help.

So I guessed that there might be a parasite that was storing those settings: if the JPEG save plug-in sees the parasite, it uses those values and doesn't prompt. Using the Python console technique I just mentioned, I tried checking the parasites on a newly created image and on an image read in from an existing JPG file, then saving each one as JPG and checking the parasite list afterward.

Bingo! When you read in a JPG file, it has a parasite called 'jpeg-settings'. (The new image doesn't have this, naturally). But after you write a file to JPG from within GIMP, it has not only 'jpeg-settings' but also a second parasite, 'jpeg-save-options'.

So I made the plug-in check the scaled image after saving it, looking for any parasites with names ending in either -settings or -save-options; any such parasites are copied to the original image. Then, the next time you invoke Export Scaled, it does the same search, and copies those parasites to the scaled image before calling gimp-file-save.

That darned invisible JPG settings dialog

One niggling annoyance remained. The first time you get the JPG settings dialog, it pops up invisibly, under the Export dialog you're using. So if you didn't know to look for it by moving the dialog, you'd think the plug-in had frozen. GIMP 2.6 had a bug where that happened every time I saved, so I assumed there was nothing I can do about it.

GIMP 2.8 has fixed that bug -- yet it still happened when my plug-in called gimp_file_save: the JPG dialog popped up under the currently active dialog, at least under Openbox.

There isn't any way to pass window IDs through gimp_file_save so the JPG dialog pops up as transient to a particular window. But a few days after I wrote the export-scaled, I realized there was still something I could do: hide the dialog when the user clicks Save. Then make sure that I show it again if any errors occur during saving.

Of course, it wasn't quite that simple. Calling chooser.hide() by itself does nothing, because X is asynchronous and things don't happen in any predictable order. But it's possible to force X to sync the display: chooser.get_display().sync().

I'm not sure how robust this is going to be -- but it seems to work well in the testing I've done so far, and it's really nice to get that huge GTK file chooser dialog out of the way as soon as possible.

Tags: , ,
[ 18:34 Sep 02, 2012    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Tue, 21 Aug 2012

GIMP: Re-uniting Save and Export

In GIMP 2.8, the developers changed the way you save files. "Save" is now used only for GIMP's native format, XCF (and compressed variants like .xcf.gz and .xcf.bz2). Other formats that may lose information on layers, fonts and other aspects of the edited image must be "Exported" rather than saved.

This has caused much consternation and flameage on the gimp-user mailing list, especially from people who use GIMP primarily for simple edits to JPEG or PNG files.

I don't particularly like the new model myself. Sometimes I use GIMP in the way the developers are encouraging, adding dozens of layers, fonts, layer masks and other effects. Much more often, I use GIMP to crop and rescale a handful of JPG photos I took with my camera on a hike. While I found it easy enough to adapt to using Ctrl-E (Export) instead of Ctrl-S (Save), it was annoying that when I exited the app, I'd always get am "Unsaved images" warning, and it was impossible to tell from the warning dialog which images were safely exported and which might not have been saved or exported at all.

But flaming on the mailing lists, much as some people seem to enjoy it (500 messages on the subject and still counting!) wasn't the answer. The developers have stated very clearly that they're not going to change the model back. So is there another solution?

Yes -- a very simple solution, in fact. Write a plug-in that saves or exports the current image back to its current file name, then marks it as clean so GIMP won't warn about it when you quit.

It turned out to be extremely easy to write, and you can get it here: GIMP: Save/export clean plug-in. If it suits your GIMP workflow, you can even bind it to Ctrl-S ... or any other key you like.

Warning: I deliberately did not add any "Are you sure you want to overwrite?" confirmation dialogs. This plug-in will overwrite your current file, without asking for permission. After all, that's its job. So be aware of that.

How it's written

Here are some details about how it works. Non software geeks can skip the rest of this article.

When I first looked into writing this, I was amazed at how simple it was: really just two lines of Python (plus the usual plug-in registration boilerplate).

    pdb.gimp_file_save(img, drawable, img.filename, img.filename)
    pdb.gimp_image_clean_all(img)

The first line saves the image back to its current filename. (The gimp-file-save PDB call still handles all types, not just XCF.) The second line marks the image as clean.

Both of those are PDB calls, which means that people who don't have GIMP Python could write script-fu to do this part.

So why didn't I use script-fu? Because I quickly found that if I bound the plug-in to Ctrl-S, I'd want to use it for new images -- images that don't have a filename yet. And for that, you need to pop up some sort of "Save as" dialog -- something Python can do easily, and Script-fu can't do at all.

A Save-as dialog with smart directory default

I couldn't use the standard GIMP save-as dialog: as far as I can tell, there's no way to call that dialog from a plug-in. But it turned out the GTK save-as dialog has no default directory to start in: you have to set the starting directory every time. So I needed a reasonable initial directory.

I didn't want to come up with some desktop twaddle like ~/My Pictures or whatever -- is there really anyone that model fits? Certainly not me. I debated maintaining a preference you could set, or saving the last used directory as a preference, but that complicates things and I wasn't sure it's really that helpful for most people anyway.

So I thought about where I usually want to save images in a GIMP session. Usually, I want to save them to the same directory where I've been saving other images in the same session, right?

I can figure that out by looping through all currently open images with for img in gimp.image_list() : and checking os.path.dirname(img.filename) for each one. Keep track of how many times each directory is being used; whichever is used the most times is probably where the user wants to store the next image.

Keeping count in Python

Looping through is easy, but what's the cleanest, most Pythonic way of maintaining the count for each directory and finding the most popular one? Naturally, Python has a class for that, collections.Counter.

Once I've counted everything, I can ask for the most common path. The code looks a bit complicated because most_common(1) returns a one-item list of a tuple of the single most common path and the number of times it's been used -- for instance, [ ('/home/akkana/public_html/images/birds', 5) ]. So the path is the first element of the first element, or most_common(1)[0][0]. Put it together:

    counts = collections.Counter()
    for img in gimp.image_list() :
        if img.filename :
            counts[os.path.dirname(img.filename)] += 1
    try :
        return counts.most_common(1)[0][0]
    except :
        return None

So that's the only tricky part of this plug-in. The rest is straightforward, and you can read the code on GitHub: save-export-clean.py.

Tags: , ,
[ 12:26 Aug 21, 2012    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Wed, 13 Apr 2011

GIMP: Build-it

Are you a GIMP user or Summer of Code student who's been wanting to get involved, but having trouble building, or a bit intimidated by the build process?

I'll be running a session on IRC to help anyone build GIMP on Linux, as part of the OpenHatch "Build it" project.

The session will take place on #gimp on irc.gimp.org (also known as GimpNet), on Fri, Apr 15, 0300 UTC -- that's Thursday night in the Americas. To convert to your time zone, run this command on your local machine:

$ date -d 'Fri Apr 15 03:00 UTC'
Thu Apr 14 20:00:00 PDT 2011
Or try this link: world time server.

This is a time that's usually fairly quiet on #gimp -- European users don't fret, since it's pretty easy to get help there during more Europe-friendly time zones. I'll hang around for at least two hours; that should be plenty of time to build GIMP and all its prerequisites.

For folks new to IRC, note that irc.gimp.org is its own server -- this is not the #gimp channel on Freenode. You can learn more about IRC on the LinuxChix IRC for Beginners page, or, if you have trouble getting an IRC client configured, try this link for mibbit web chat.

Note: The #gimp IRC channel was recently under attack by trolls, and it's possible that it may not be usable at the time of the session. In that case, I will update this blog page with the name of an alternate channel to use, and any other necessarily details.

Preparation

If you want to get your system set up ahead of time, I've put the instructions needed to build on Ubuntu Lucid and other older Linux distros here: Gimp Building Tips (for Linux). I might be able to offer a little help with building on Macs, but no guarantees.

Mac and Windows users, or people running a very old Linux distro (more than a year old) might want to consider an alternate approach: install Virtualbox or VMware and install Ubuntu "Natty Narwhal" (currently still in beta) in a virtual machine.

Of course, this isn't the only time you can get help with building GIMP. There are folks around on #gimp most of the time who are happy to help with problems. But if you've been meaning to get started and want a good excuse, or you've been holding off on asking for help ... come hang out with us and try it!

Tags: , ,
[ 12:50 Apr 13, 2011    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Sat, 19 Feb 2011

GIMP: Don't get confused by the Auto button

A couple of people recently have appeared on GIMP IRC channels wondering why no filters or layer operations seemed to work in GIMP, even though they had an image open.

In at least one case, it was a setting most of us had forgotten about: the Auto button. It's easy to miss, but if you turn it on accidentally, you may be unable to do anything in GIMP until you realize what's happened. [Normal layers dialog, auto]

The Auto button is the one at the upper right of your Layers dialog. It's on by default, and what it does is ensure that dialogs like Layers, and GIMP's notion of the currently active layer, follow the active image. Open a new image, or click in a different image window, and your Layers dialog switches images -- so whatever you do next will apply to the image you just chose. [Layers dialog with Auto off]

If you turn Auto off, then by default, no image and no layer is active. Notice, in the screenshot at left, how no image is shown in the option menu just left of the Auto button.

Even if you open a new image, you can't do anything with it until you explicitly choose an image from the menu.

I'm sure you can see why this could be confusing. So why have that button at all?

Well, it's useful when you're working with lots of images -- for instance, if you want to drag a layer from one image into another image, you can use the menu to switch quickly among images and layers without needing to bring those image windows to the front. I don't find I need it, but for those who do, I guess it can be a real time-saver.
[that pesky GIMP Auto menu]

Just to make it even more confusing, not everyone even has the Auto button or the menu next to it. You can turn it off (and gain a little extra vertical space for your layers dialog) with the tiny menu button right above the mode menu. "Show Image Selection" controls whether the image option menu, and the Auto button next to it, will be displayed. "Auto Follow Active Image" is the same toggle as the Auto button itself.

So if you ever get stuck and the Layers dialog doesn't seem to be showing layers from your image, and you can't figure out why ... remember that pesky Auto button. It might just be the problem.

(If not, try quitting GIMP and moving your profile aside. That works for curing all manner of mysterious ills -- including this one. Come to think of it, that deserves an article of its own. Coming soon!)

Tags: ,
[ 11:04 Feb 19, 2011    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Fri, 18 Feb 2011

New GIMP Arrow Designer

[arrow] While writing a blog post on GIMP's confusing Auto button (to be posted soon), I needed some arrows, and discovered a bug in my Arrow Designer script when making arrows that are mostly vertical.

So I fixed it. You can get the new Arrow Designer 0.5 on my GIMP Arrow Designer page.

It's purely a coincidence that I discovered this a week before SCALE, where I'll be speaking on Writing GIMP Scripts and Plug-Ins. Arrow Designer is one of my showpieces for making interactive plug-ins with GIMP-Python, so I'm glad I noticed the bug when I did.

Tags: , ,
[ 21:28 Feb 18, 2011    More gimp | permalink to this entry | comments ]

Syndicated on:
LinuxChix Live
Ubuntu Women
Women in Free Software
Graphics Planet
DevChix
Ubuntu California
Planet Openbox
Devchix
Planet LCA2009

Friends' Blogs:
Morris "Mojo" Jones
Jane Houston Jones
Dan Heller
Long Live the Village Green
Ups & Downs
DailyBBG

Other Blogs of Interest:
DevChix
Scott Adams
Dave Barry
BoingBoing

Powered by PyBlosxom.